Apparently, there are 2 Neafus cemeteries:

1. Neafus Cemetery Inc.
1231 Windy Ridge Rd, Caneyville, KY, 42721
(270) 879-9247 
Co. President: Wendal Embry 
*This one is located in Grayson County.  At Find a Grave it is listed in the town of "Do Stop."

2. Another is located on Neafus Road, Neafus, KY which is located in Butler County.